When assessing a child, I do believe a child should be assessed
holistically. For example, I do not take test well when I am tired, hungry, and
stressed, and because I become nervous and anxious. During the testing, I have
anxiety; but afterwards, I do well. A person should assess me through writing a
paper, portfolio, or observations that are not timed; I will fare much better,
with little anxiety. When assessing children, all of these factors should be
consider; what if the child did not get any rest the night before, what if they
are hungry, what if they had a bad morning at home? All of these things affect
a child positively or negatively; therefore, many assessment tools in a variety
of environments should be used to evaluate a child’s progress. I believe a child
should be assessed emotionally, intellectually, and physically; the more things
you assess, the better a child will fare. The more evaluative tools used in
these assessments will forecast a delay if one is present. Everyone in the
world is different and learns in different ways; therefore, each person cannot
be evaluated on the same continuum. An individual must be evaluated according
to what will work best for him or her; educated individuals will recognize this
and find a method befitting for the situation as well as the individual.
While looking at this question, I already knew what area of the
world I would research concerning this topic. Assessments vary over different sections
of the world; I have always been intrigued by China and their culture. I do not
want to sound bias but, I believe China’s children fare better in school and in
social status compared to other places; because of the discipline and respect,
they have for their families and culture. I know their culture believes in all work
and no play, but they are excelling in many ways. I do not agree with making a
child sit all day long doing class or homework, but I do believe that we should have
some form of discipline when it comes to school, work, and the important things
in life. Although China is rigorous in their form of schooling, most of their
children are very intelligent and disciplined. China’s children are not well
rounded because; they focus more on education and less on play. I found an article
that explains China’s skill assessment system, and how it relates to their
children, progress, and labor markets. In old China, education was not
important and it was looked over; now in New China, education is more important.
According to Zhang (2004), “China probably has the longest history of tests and
examinations in the world.” This goes to show how strict China is in regards to
education and assessments. Their children primary entry level for school is age
six, and they must take an end of term exam, as well as an end of year and
primary graduation exam (Zhang). Zhang goes on to discuss how tests and exams
are still the exclusive determining factor for promoting students into higher
levels of education. I continued to read the article and I found a chart on page
five and six that shows how the children are being assessed in China according
to their age and grade. This
article has a lot of great information regarding standards and assessments.
As early childhood
educators, it is our job to educate children as well as adults on the ever-changing
research in this world. We should strive to teach those who need to learn. We should
show them a better way to get an understanding of what development should and
should not look like. We should continue to advocate and change the way people
perceive our children and fight for new and improved methods for assessing and
evaluating children. As educators, we have learned what assessments are appropriate
or not appropriate for young children. We should advocate to parents and other
professionals regarding appropriate practices and evaluating tools. Let us make
a difference in the lives of ALL.
Reference
Zhang, J. (2004). China’s
Skill Assessment System. Institute of Population and Labor Economics Chinese              Academy of Social
Sciences. Retrieved from http://siteresources.worldbank.org/EDUCATION/Resources/278200-                1126210664195/1636971-1126210694253/China_Skills_Assessment.pdf                                   
Lah-Lah
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed your view of assessment. As you stated the factors that can play into the outcome of an assessment. Therefore the assessment wouldn't reflect accurately. What do you think would happen if there were no formal assessments before age 5?
I have always been intrigued by the Chinese and their strong academic face. I do have strong respect for that. I try to look at the WHOLE child. If we forget one part then there is an imbalance. Could there be an imbalance especially after learning how play is necessary for healthy development?
Great post, as always Lah Lah!
Catherine
I do not think there is a need for a formal assessment prior to three or four years of age, if you are familiar with your child. Educators know and are familiar with typical developing children; if you engage with a child daily, you will know if something is not right with the child; therefore, if there is an issue, an assessment would be necessary.
DeleteThere will definitely be an imbalance if children are not allowed to play and explore in their environment. This is how they naturally grow and develop.
Lah-Lah,
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading your blog. I agree with you that if a child is hungry, stressed, or tired that these factors need to be taken into consideration before screening or assessing a child. If a child is tired, he or she may not comprehend well while being screened and may receive a failing score. I know that I do not function well when doing homework or taking a test if I do not get enough sleep or if I am hungry.
Erica Smith
Lah-Lah,
ReplyDeleteI really appreciate your comment about how a child should be assessed holistically. It's great to point out that children will not test well if they are tired, hungry, uncomfortable, etc. I completely agree that data should be retrieved in various environments during different times so that we can put together a more accurate depiction of the child. I agree with you that the children in China are well educated, however I sometimes wonder how much impact the loss of childhood play will have on them later in life. What experiences have been forever lost...it's sad in a way.
It is sad.
DeleteLah Lah,
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with you, I don't perform well on test because I start to work about the timing and I make myself so nervous I start to secong guess my answers even when it is on a topic I know a lot about. I also used China for my blog assignment and I found that tey use a few diffrent ways to assess thier students, one of which was new to me; peer assesment. I think using diffrent assesments will allow for children to show what they know in a way that is comfortable for them.
Hello Lah Lah,
ReplyDeleteYou have shared interesting details in your presentation. I can relate on the matters of children becoming too nervous during test, assessment. I noticed that over the year some educators tend to hide the matter of a child being evaluated to the child themselves. They believe that if a child it is a test, automatically they will perform low. However, some educators set-up a test in which is fun and creative so children will engage and believes they are not being tested, but actually they are being evaluated. In other words distracts fear and low attention span.
Tanya Terrell
That is a good point; when I asses my children i make it fun and exciting. Well, I make everything fun and exciting, that is how I am.
DeleteThanks for the reply,
Lah-Lah